Win by any means

Both bloodlusted

ROTS Mace > KF Vader. ROTS Mace is a Yoda/Sidious level opponent. Only Full potential Anakin can beat them.

CW Mace would likely lose to KF Vader though.

The power scaling of Mace between CW and ROTS is a bit messy. Multiple sources during CW put Mace as a Dooku level opponent, but in ROTS and by Lucas's word Mace is a Yoda/Sidious level fighter. It's hard to reconcile the two so I just view them as separate.

I swear this had been done a hundred times

Anakin after a good fight.

Prime Anakin would be him on Mortis with his chosen one boost I blieve. He could force stomp Mace during that time.

If we are talking besides that, then I would give Mace the edge due to being more experienced and his duel with Sidiouis is better than anything Anakin has done. Either way though it would be a close fight.

Anakin

KF Annie vs Vaapad Windu is pretty close, but I'd back Annie more often than not.

Prime Anakin wins. Not only is he actually confirmed to be in the Yoda/Sidious range, he's one tier above Mace.

The Skywalker, good fight.

The Skywalker, good fight.

The Hero With No Fear

Remember full potential Anakin was considered by George Lucas to be nye unstoppable much more powerful than he was when he was vader

I think it's safe to say if they actually fought in the movie though Anakin would win via plot reasons, just like the ROTS VG. Not that I wouldn't have minded seeing it.

Anakin wins. He is stronger, somewhat faster, and just as skilled.

Can you define 'Prime Anakin' for me please? And the location of the fight? I just have a hard time seeing Skywalker Sr. winning via lightsaber combat.

Windu. ROTS Anakin gets a boost in power when he’s Angry but that won’t help him this time since Windu is adapt to fighting Dark Side / Anger, he’s also been said to be only number 2 to Yoda. Plus let’s not forget ROTS Anakin power grew when he submitted himself to the dark side, and was STILL stalemated by Obi Wan, who is still weaker than Mace and Sidious.

The Darth Sidious confrontation is somewhat controversial on who could have really won between Sidious and Mace, had Anakin not arrived. But I’ll side with Windu who has better experience and is used to fighting Raw power.

Anakin stomps