In this scenario, Captain America(Earth-616 Comic Steve Rogers) swaps places with Geralt during the events of Flotsam (Ch. 1 Witcher 2) and the plot progresses from there. Captain does not have his shield but does come equipped with all of Geralts standard equipment. He does not have knowledge of the world he was dropped into or how he got there but the friendly NPC's guide him through the story line proper thinking he is a version of Geralt who is once again suffering from amnesia.

From the start point to the the end of the Witcher 3 storyline, how long would Cap survive or would he complete it?

Bonus: How many ladies would Cap seduce on his journey if any at all?

He dies for sure to that Kraken thing.

@emperorb777:

I don't know, he can throw a shield through a tank. He could possibly throw a sword straight throigh the kraken.

@slimj87d: Well the Kraken stays underwater until you cut off it's limbs but Cap doesn't have the sign that stops the limbs from moving so he can't cut them off. If he throws his swords he would no longer have any means of defeating the creature.

Depends on the Cap if its comic cap he should be able to make it through a lot if its MCU Cap he dies very early

@marvelanddcfan24: Ah, Ill specify then. Its 616 Comic Steve Rogers.

@emperorb777:

It'll definitely be hard without magic but I think he can easily avoid the tentacles if the kraken fights like the way it fought Geralt. Cap should be able to cut the tentacles apart with the speed and agility he has shown.

Wont he be awkwardly cornered by all the witches who want to sleep with him?

Dies to either the keyran or Letho.

Without Yrden he's unable to immobilize keyran's tentacles and with Letho he's lack of personal history between them makes Letho go all-out.

Regarding bonus round, I can see him getting laid as often as Geralt, due to his good looks and personal charm. Wheter he can satisfy them as well as Geralt is questionable though.

Gets killed by the Kayran.

But I think this would be better if it was the whole series rather than just one game.

@lubub55: Well its supposed to be from Witcher 2- Witcher 3. But I guess I overestimated Cap and he dies to an oversized squid before the journey even starts lol