creating same values within a group using retain statement in SAS









up vote
1
down vote

favorite
1












I am trying to create a variable z that will take the same value within a group based on values of two variables X and Y of the first observation within a group. There are 4 possible values of Z a group can take based on the X and Y values of the first observation in the group.



Z=1 (if X=1 & Y=1), 
Z=2 (if X=2 & Y=1),
Z=3 (if X=1 & Y=2), and
Z=4 (if X=2 & Y=2).


This is what I have and what I want.



X has two values, 1 or 2, within a group; while Y can take 1, 2 ,3. 
Y is sorted in ascending order
if the first (or all group observations) take a value of 3, the resulting Z
value should be set to missing


This is what I have:



Obs Group X Y
1 10600 1 1
2 10600 1 2
3 10600 1 3
4 10800 2 1
5 10800 2 3
6 10900 1 2
7 10900 1 3
8 11100 2 2
9 11100 2 2
10 11100 2 3
11 11100 2 2
12 11200 2 3
13 11300 2 1
14 11300 2 2
15 11300 1 3
16 11300 1 3
17 11300 1 3
18 11300 1 3


And here is what I want:



Obs Group X Y Z
1 10600 1 1 1
2 10600 1 2 1
3 10600 1 3 1
4 10800 2 1 2
5 10800 2 3 2
6 10900 1 2 3
7 10900 1 3 3
8 11100 2 2 4
9 11100 2 2 4
10 11100 2 3 4
11 11100 2 2 4
12 11200 2 3 .
13 11300 2 1 2
14 11300 2 2 2
15 11300 1 3 .
16 11300 1 3 .
17 11300 1 3 .
18 11300 1 3 .


Thank you!










share|improve this question



























    up vote
    1
    down vote

    favorite
    1












    I am trying to create a variable z that will take the same value within a group based on values of two variables X and Y of the first observation within a group. There are 4 possible values of Z a group can take based on the X and Y values of the first observation in the group.



    Z=1 (if X=1 & Y=1), 
    Z=2 (if X=2 & Y=1),
    Z=3 (if X=1 & Y=2), and
    Z=4 (if X=2 & Y=2).


    This is what I have and what I want.



    X has two values, 1 or 2, within a group; while Y can take 1, 2 ,3. 
    Y is sorted in ascending order
    if the first (or all group observations) take a value of 3, the resulting Z
    value should be set to missing


    This is what I have:



    Obs Group X Y
    1 10600 1 1
    2 10600 1 2
    3 10600 1 3
    4 10800 2 1
    5 10800 2 3
    6 10900 1 2
    7 10900 1 3
    8 11100 2 2
    9 11100 2 2
    10 11100 2 3
    11 11100 2 2
    12 11200 2 3
    13 11300 2 1
    14 11300 2 2
    15 11300 1 3
    16 11300 1 3
    17 11300 1 3
    18 11300 1 3


    And here is what I want:



    Obs Group X Y Z
    1 10600 1 1 1
    2 10600 1 2 1
    3 10600 1 3 1
    4 10800 2 1 2
    5 10800 2 3 2
    6 10900 1 2 3
    7 10900 1 3 3
    8 11100 2 2 4
    9 11100 2 2 4
    10 11100 2 3 4
    11 11100 2 2 4
    12 11200 2 3 .
    13 11300 2 1 2
    14 11300 2 2 2
    15 11300 1 3 .
    16 11300 1 3 .
    17 11300 1 3 .
    18 11300 1 3 .


    Thank you!










    share|improve this question

























      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite
      1









      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite
      1






      1





      I am trying to create a variable z that will take the same value within a group based on values of two variables X and Y of the first observation within a group. There are 4 possible values of Z a group can take based on the X and Y values of the first observation in the group.



      Z=1 (if X=1 & Y=1), 
      Z=2 (if X=2 & Y=1),
      Z=3 (if X=1 & Y=2), and
      Z=4 (if X=2 & Y=2).


      This is what I have and what I want.



      X has two values, 1 or 2, within a group; while Y can take 1, 2 ,3. 
      Y is sorted in ascending order
      if the first (or all group observations) take a value of 3, the resulting Z
      value should be set to missing


      This is what I have:



      Obs Group X Y
      1 10600 1 1
      2 10600 1 2
      3 10600 1 3
      4 10800 2 1
      5 10800 2 3
      6 10900 1 2
      7 10900 1 3
      8 11100 2 2
      9 11100 2 2
      10 11100 2 3
      11 11100 2 2
      12 11200 2 3
      13 11300 2 1
      14 11300 2 2
      15 11300 1 3
      16 11300 1 3
      17 11300 1 3
      18 11300 1 3


      And here is what I want:



      Obs Group X Y Z
      1 10600 1 1 1
      2 10600 1 2 1
      3 10600 1 3 1
      4 10800 2 1 2
      5 10800 2 3 2
      6 10900 1 2 3
      7 10900 1 3 3
      8 11100 2 2 4
      9 11100 2 2 4
      10 11100 2 3 4
      11 11100 2 2 4
      12 11200 2 3 .
      13 11300 2 1 2
      14 11300 2 2 2
      15 11300 1 3 .
      16 11300 1 3 .
      17 11300 1 3 .
      18 11300 1 3 .


      Thank you!










      share|improve this question















      I am trying to create a variable z that will take the same value within a group based on values of two variables X and Y of the first observation within a group. There are 4 possible values of Z a group can take based on the X and Y values of the first observation in the group.



      Z=1 (if X=1 & Y=1), 
      Z=2 (if X=2 & Y=1),
      Z=3 (if X=1 & Y=2), and
      Z=4 (if X=2 & Y=2).


      This is what I have and what I want.



      X has two values, 1 or 2, within a group; while Y can take 1, 2 ,3. 
      Y is sorted in ascending order
      if the first (or all group observations) take a value of 3, the resulting Z
      value should be set to missing


      This is what I have:



      Obs Group X Y
      1 10600 1 1
      2 10600 1 2
      3 10600 1 3
      4 10800 2 1
      5 10800 2 3
      6 10900 1 2
      7 10900 1 3
      8 11100 2 2
      9 11100 2 2
      10 11100 2 3
      11 11100 2 2
      12 11200 2 3
      13 11300 2 1
      14 11300 2 2
      15 11300 1 3
      16 11300 1 3
      17 11300 1 3
      18 11300 1 3


      And here is what I want:



      Obs Group X Y Z
      1 10600 1 1 1
      2 10600 1 2 1
      3 10600 1 3 1
      4 10800 2 1 2
      5 10800 2 3 2
      6 10900 1 2 3
      7 10900 1 3 3
      8 11100 2 2 4
      9 11100 2 2 4
      10 11100 2 3 4
      11 11100 2 2 4
      12 11200 2 3 .
      13 11300 2 1 2
      14 11300 2 2 2
      15 11300 1 3 .
      16 11300 1 3 .
      17 11300 1 3 .
      18 11300 1 3 .


      Thank you!







      sas retain






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited Nov 9 at 22:30









      Richard

      7,31821125




      7,31821125










      asked Nov 9 at 17:24









      stunt

      156




      156






















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes

















          up vote
          1
          down vote



          accepted










          You are correct that a retained variable will carry a value into forward iterations of the data step. Nominally, a simple data step with a single set statement an iteration will correspond to a row in the data set.



          Your retained variable is to be assigned at the start of a group, so you will need a by statement, which in turn makes an automatic flag variable first.<by-group-var> available.



          data have; input
          Group X Y; datalines;
          10600 1 1
          10600 1 2
          10600 1 3
          10800 2 1
          10800 2 3
          10900 1 2
          10900 1 3
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 3
          11100 2 2
          11200 2 3
          11300 2 1
          11300 2 2
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          run;


          The last set of rows with group=11300 have x=2 followed by x=1. Your narrative




          within a group




          conveys an idea but is not explicitly precise. The actual grouping (based on the shown want) appears to be a combination of group and x. Thus, you will need a



          by group x notsorted;


          statement. The notsorted will cause the data step setup the first. and last. based on continguity of the values instead of the explicit ordering of values.



          data want;
          set have;
          by group x nostsorted;
          retain z;
          if first.x then do; * detect first row in combinations "group/x";
          select;
          when (X=1 & Y=1) Z=1; * apply logic for retained value;
          when (X=2 & Y=1) Z=2;
          when (X=1 & Y=2) Z=3;
          when (X=2 & Y=2) Z=4;
          otherwise Z=.;
          end;
          end;
          logic_tracker_first_x = first.x;
          run;

          ods listing; options nocenter;
          proc print data=want;
          run;


          The output window shows



           logic_tracker_
          Obs Group X Y z first_x

          1 10600 1 1 1 1
          2 10600 1 2 1 0
          3 10600 1 3 1 0
          4 10800 2 1 2 1
          5 10800 2 3 2 0
          6 10900 1 2 3 1
          7 10900 1 3 3 0
          8 11100 2 2 4 1
          9 11100 2 2 4 0
          10 11100 2 3 4 0
          11 11100 2 2 4 0
          12 11200 2 3 . 1
          13 11300 2 1 2 1
          14 11300 2 2 2 0
          15 11300 1 3 . 1
          16 11300 1 3 . 0
          17 11300 1 3 . 0
          18 11300 1 3 . 0





          share|improve this answer






















          • Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:07











          • See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
            – Richard
            Nov 11 at 15:23










          • Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:02

















          up vote
          1
          down vote













          please try using the following solution , I have used simpler approach by keeping only First Z variable per Group and then did a left join with same dataset to keep the First z variable across remaining observations for same group-



          data test;
          input group 5. x 1. y 1.;
          if x=1 and y=1 then z=1;
          else if x=2 and y=1 then z=2;
          else if x=1 and y=2 then z=3;
          else if x=2 and y=2 then z=4;
          datalines;
          1060011
          1060012
          1060013
          1080021
          1080023
          1090012
          1090013
          1110022
          1110022
          1110023
          1110022
          1120023
          1130021
          1130022
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          ;
          run;

          data test1;
          set test;
          keep group x z;
          run;

          proc sort data=test1; by group x; run;

          data keep_first;
          set test1;
          by group x;
          if first.group or first.x;
          run;

          proc sql;
          create table final
          as
          select a.group, a.x, a.y, b.z
          from test a
          left join keep_first b
          on a.group=b.group
          and a.x=b.x
          order by a.group, a.y, a.x;
          quit;





          share|improve this answer




















          • There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
            – Richard
            Nov 9 at 22:33










          • yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
            – Rhythm
            Nov 9 at 22:34










          • Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
            – Richard
            Nov 10 at 1:06










          • Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:10










          • Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:07










          Your Answer






          StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function ()
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function ()
          StackExchange.snippets.init();
          );
          );
          , "code-snippets");

          StackExchange.ready(function()
          var channelOptions =
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "1"
          ;
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
          createEditor();
          );

          else
          createEditor();

          );

          function createEditor()
          StackExchange.prepareEditor(
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          convertImagesToLinks: true,
          noModals: true,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: 10,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          imageUploader:
          brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
          contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
          allowUrls: true
          ,
          onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          );



          );













           

          draft saved


          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53230571%2fcreating-same-values-within-a-group-using-retain-statement-in-sas%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown

























          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes








          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes








          up vote
          1
          down vote



          accepted










          You are correct that a retained variable will carry a value into forward iterations of the data step. Nominally, a simple data step with a single set statement an iteration will correspond to a row in the data set.



          Your retained variable is to be assigned at the start of a group, so you will need a by statement, which in turn makes an automatic flag variable first.<by-group-var> available.



          data have; input
          Group X Y; datalines;
          10600 1 1
          10600 1 2
          10600 1 3
          10800 2 1
          10800 2 3
          10900 1 2
          10900 1 3
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 3
          11100 2 2
          11200 2 3
          11300 2 1
          11300 2 2
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          run;


          The last set of rows with group=11300 have x=2 followed by x=1. Your narrative




          within a group




          conveys an idea but is not explicitly precise. The actual grouping (based on the shown want) appears to be a combination of group and x. Thus, you will need a



          by group x notsorted;


          statement. The notsorted will cause the data step setup the first. and last. based on continguity of the values instead of the explicit ordering of values.



          data want;
          set have;
          by group x nostsorted;
          retain z;
          if first.x then do; * detect first row in combinations "group/x";
          select;
          when (X=1 & Y=1) Z=1; * apply logic for retained value;
          when (X=2 & Y=1) Z=2;
          when (X=1 & Y=2) Z=3;
          when (X=2 & Y=2) Z=4;
          otherwise Z=.;
          end;
          end;
          logic_tracker_first_x = first.x;
          run;

          ods listing; options nocenter;
          proc print data=want;
          run;


          The output window shows



           logic_tracker_
          Obs Group X Y z first_x

          1 10600 1 1 1 1
          2 10600 1 2 1 0
          3 10600 1 3 1 0
          4 10800 2 1 2 1
          5 10800 2 3 2 0
          6 10900 1 2 3 1
          7 10900 1 3 3 0
          8 11100 2 2 4 1
          9 11100 2 2 4 0
          10 11100 2 3 4 0
          11 11100 2 2 4 0
          12 11200 2 3 . 1
          13 11300 2 1 2 1
          14 11300 2 2 2 0
          15 11300 1 3 . 1
          16 11300 1 3 . 0
          17 11300 1 3 . 0
          18 11300 1 3 . 0





          share|improve this answer






















          • Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:07











          • See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
            – Richard
            Nov 11 at 15:23










          • Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:02














          up vote
          1
          down vote



          accepted










          You are correct that a retained variable will carry a value into forward iterations of the data step. Nominally, a simple data step with a single set statement an iteration will correspond to a row in the data set.



          Your retained variable is to be assigned at the start of a group, so you will need a by statement, which in turn makes an automatic flag variable first.<by-group-var> available.



          data have; input
          Group X Y; datalines;
          10600 1 1
          10600 1 2
          10600 1 3
          10800 2 1
          10800 2 3
          10900 1 2
          10900 1 3
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 3
          11100 2 2
          11200 2 3
          11300 2 1
          11300 2 2
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          run;


          The last set of rows with group=11300 have x=2 followed by x=1. Your narrative




          within a group




          conveys an idea but is not explicitly precise. The actual grouping (based on the shown want) appears to be a combination of group and x. Thus, you will need a



          by group x notsorted;


          statement. The notsorted will cause the data step setup the first. and last. based on continguity of the values instead of the explicit ordering of values.



          data want;
          set have;
          by group x nostsorted;
          retain z;
          if first.x then do; * detect first row in combinations "group/x";
          select;
          when (X=1 & Y=1) Z=1; * apply logic for retained value;
          when (X=2 & Y=1) Z=2;
          when (X=1 & Y=2) Z=3;
          when (X=2 & Y=2) Z=4;
          otherwise Z=.;
          end;
          end;
          logic_tracker_first_x = first.x;
          run;

          ods listing; options nocenter;
          proc print data=want;
          run;


          The output window shows



           logic_tracker_
          Obs Group X Y z first_x

          1 10600 1 1 1 1
          2 10600 1 2 1 0
          3 10600 1 3 1 0
          4 10800 2 1 2 1
          5 10800 2 3 2 0
          6 10900 1 2 3 1
          7 10900 1 3 3 0
          8 11100 2 2 4 1
          9 11100 2 2 4 0
          10 11100 2 3 4 0
          11 11100 2 2 4 0
          12 11200 2 3 . 1
          13 11300 2 1 2 1
          14 11300 2 2 2 0
          15 11300 1 3 . 1
          16 11300 1 3 . 0
          17 11300 1 3 . 0
          18 11300 1 3 . 0





          share|improve this answer






















          • Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:07











          • See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
            – Richard
            Nov 11 at 15:23










          • Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:02












          up vote
          1
          down vote



          accepted







          up vote
          1
          down vote



          accepted






          You are correct that a retained variable will carry a value into forward iterations of the data step. Nominally, a simple data step with a single set statement an iteration will correspond to a row in the data set.



          Your retained variable is to be assigned at the start of a group, so you will need a by statement, which in turn makes an automatic flag variable first.<by-group-var> available.



          data have; input
          Group X Y; datalines;
          10600 1 1
          10600 1 2
          10600 1 3
          10800 2 1
          10800 2 3
          10900 1 2
          10900 1 3
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 3
          11100 2 2
          11200 2 3
          11300 2 1
          11300 2 2
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          run;


          The last set of rows with group=11300 have x=2 followed by x=1. Your narrative




          within a group




          conveys an idea but is not explicitly precise. The actual grouping (based on the shown want) appears to be a combination of group and x. Thus, you will need a



          by group x notsorted;


          statement. The notsorted will cause the data step setup the first. and last. based on continguity of the values instead of the explicit ordering of values.



          data want;
          set have;
          by group x nostsorted;
          retain z;
          if first.x then do; * detect first row in combinations "group/x";
          select;
          when (X=1 & Y=1) Z=1; * apply logic for retained value;
          when (X=2 & Y=1) Z=2;
          when (X=1 & Y=2) Z=3;
          when (X=2 & Y=2) Z=4;
          otherwise Z=.;
          end;
          end;
          logic_tracker_first_x = first.x;
          run;

          ods listing; options nocenter;
          proc print data=want;
          run;


          The output window shows



           logic_tracker_
          Obs Group X Y z first_x

          1 10600 1 1 1 1
          2 10600 1 2 1 0
          3 10600 1 3 1 0
          4 10800 2 1 2 1
          5 10800 2 3 2 0
          6 10900 1 2 3 1
          7 10900 1 3 3 0
          8 11100 2 2 4 1
          9 11100 2 2 4 0
          10 11100 2 3 4 0
          11 11100 2 2 4 0
          12 11200 2 3 . 1
          13 11300 2 1 2 1
          14 11300 2 2 2 0
          15 11300 1 3 . 1
          16 11300 1 3 . 0
          17 11300 1 3 . 0
          18 11300 1 3 . 0





          share|improve this answer














          You are correct that a retained variable will carry a value into forward iterations of the data step. Nominally, a simple data step with a single set statement an iteration will correspond to a row in the data set.



          Your retained variable is to be assigned at the start of a group, so you will need a by statement, which in turn makes an automatic flag variable first.<by-group-var> available.



          data have; input
          Group X Y; datalines;
          10600 1 1
          10600 1 2
          10600 1 3
          10800 2 1
          10800 2 3
          10900 1 2
          10900 1 3
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 2
          11100 2 3
          11100 2 2
          11200 2 3
          11300 2 1
          11300 2 2
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          11300 1 3
          run;


          The last set of rows with group=11300 have x=2 followed by x=1. Your narrative




          within a group




          conveys an idea but is not explicitly precise. The actual grouping (based on the shown want) appears to be a combination of group and x. Thus, you will need a



          by group x notsorted;


          statement. The notsorted will cause the data step setup the first. and last. based on continguity of the values instead of the explicit ordering of values.



          data want;
          set have;
          by group x nostsorted;
          retain z;
          if first.x then do; * detect first row in combinations "group/x";
          select;
          when (X=1 & Y=1) Z=1; * apply logic for retained value;
          when (X=2 & Y=1) Z=2;
          when (X=1 & Y=2) Z=3;
          when (X=2 & Y=2) Z=4;
          otherwise Z=.;
          end;
          end;
          logic_tracker_first_x = first.x;
          run;

          ods listing; options nocenter;
          proc print data=want;
          run;


          The output window shows



           logic_tracker_
          Obs Group X Y z first_x

          1 10600 1 1 1 1
          2 10600 1 2 1 0
          3 10600 1 3 1 0
          4 10800 2 1 2 1
          5 10800 2 3 2 0
          6 10900 1 2 3 1
          7 10900 1 3 3 0
          8 11100 2 2 4 1
          9 11100 2 2 4 0
          10 11100 2 3 4 0
          11 11100 2 2 4 0
          12 11200 2 3 . 1
          13 11300 2 1 2 1
          14 11300 2 2 2 0
          15 11300 1 3 . 1
          16 11300 1 3 . 0
          17 11300 1 3 . 0
          18 11300 1 3 . 0






          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Nov 11 at 16:37

























          answered Nov 9 at 22:14









          Richard

          7,31821125




          7,31821125











          • Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:07











          • See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
            – Richard
            Nov 11 at 15:23










          • Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:02
















          • Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:07











          • See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
            – Richard
            Nov 11 at 15:23










          • Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:02















          Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 15:07





          Thanks for you response. I tried this code but it gives missing values after the first within each group. Can you attempt it using the have data and see if it works. It may need a bi of tweaking. Thanks!
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 15:07













          See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
          – Richard
          Nov 11 at 15:23




          See edit, seems to work. Original was missing semi-colon after otherwise, but that should have logged an ERROR 22-322: Syntax error, expecting one of the following:... Perhaps you got the error and did not look at the log and was looking at the data output from a prior submit.
          – Richard
          Nov 11 at 15:23












          Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 21:02




          Ok thanks, that works. I think the group x notsorted is what was needed as well. Thanks very much for your help.
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 21:02












          up vote
          1
          down vote













          please try using the following solution , I have used simpler approach by keeping only First Z variable per Group and then did a left join with same dataset to keep the First z variable across remaining observations for same group-



          data test;
          input group 5. x 1. y 1.;
          if x=1 and y=1 then z=1;
          else if x=2 and y=1 then z=2;
          else if x=1 and y=2 then z=3;
          else if x=2 and y=2 then z=4;
          datalines;
          1060011
          1060012
          1060013
          1080021
          1080023
          1090012
          1090013
          1110022
          1110022
          1110023
          1110022
          1120023
          1130021
          1130022
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          ;
          run;

          data test1;
          set test;
          keep group x z;
          run;

          proc sort data=test1; by group x; run;

          data keep_first;
          set test1;
          by group x;
          if first.group or first.x;
          run;

          proc sql;
          create table final
          as
          select a.group, a.x, a.y, b.z
          from test a
          left join keep_first b
          on a.group=b.group
          and a.x=b.x
          order by a.group, a.y, a.x;
          quit;





          share|improve this answer




















          • There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
            – Richard
            Nov 9 at 22:33










          • yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
            – Rhythm
            Nov 9 at 22:34










          • Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
            – Richard
            Nov 10 at 1:06










          • Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:10










          • Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:07














          up vote
          1
          down vote













          please try using the following solution , I have used simpler approach by keeping only First Z variable per Group and then did a left join with same dataset to keep the First z variable across remaining observations for same group-



          data test;
          input group 5. x 1. y 1.;
          if x=1 and y=1 then z=1;
          else if x=2 and y=1 then z=2;
          else if x=1 and y=2 then z=3;
          else if x=2 and y=2 then z=4;
          datalines;
          1060011
          1060012
          1060013
          1080021
          1080023
          1090012
          1090013
          1110022
          1110022
          1110023
          1110022
          1120023
          1130021
          1130022
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          ;
          run;

          data test1;
          set test;
          keep group x z;
          run;

          proc sort data=test1; by group x; run;

          data keep_first;
          set test1;
          by group x;
          if first.group or first.x;
          run;

          proc sql;
          create table final
          as
          select a.group, a.x, a.y, b.z
          from test a
          left join keep_first b
          on a.group=b.group
          and a.x=b.x
          order by a.group, a.y, a.x;
          quit;





          share|improve this answer




















          • There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
            – Richard
            Nov 9 at 22:33










          • yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
            – Rhythm
            Nov 9 at 22:34










          • Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
            – Richard
            Nov 10 at 1:06










          • Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:10










          • Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:07












          up vote
          1
          down vote










          up vote
          1
          down vote









          please try using the following solution , I have used simpler approach by keeping only First Z variable per Group and then did a left join with same dataset to keep the First z variable across remaining observations for same group-



          data test;
          input group 5. x 1. y 1.;
          if x=1 and y=1 then z=1;
          else if x=2 and y=1 then z=2;
          else if x=1 and y=2 then z=3;
          else if x=2 and y=2 then z=4;
          datalines;
          1060011
          1060012
          1060013
          1080021
          1080023
          1090012
          1090013
          1110022
          1110022
          1110023
          1110022
          1120023
          1130021
          1130022
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          ;
          run;

          data test1;
          set test;
          keep group x z;
          run;

          proc sort data=test1; by group x; run;

          data keep_first;
          set test1;
          by group x;
          if first.group or first.x;
          run;

          proc sql;
          create table final
          as
          select a.group, a.x, a.y, b.z
          from test a
          left join keep_first b
          on a.group=b.group
          and a.x=b.x
          order by a.group, a.y, a.x;
          quit;





          share|improve this answer












          please try using the following solution , I have used simpler approach by keeping only First Z variable per Group and then did a left join with same dataset to keep the First z variable across remaining observations for same group-



          data test;
          input group 5. x 1. y 1.;
          if x=1 and y=1 then z=1;
          else if x=2 and y=1 then z=2;
          else if x=1 and y=2 then z=3;
          else if x=2 and y=2 then z=4;
          datalines;
          1060011
          1060012
          1060013
          1080021
          1080023
          1090012
          1090013
          1110022
          1110022
          1110023
          1110022
          1120023
          1130021
          1130022
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          1130013
          ;
          run;

          data test1;
          set test;
          keep group x z;
          run;

          proc sort data=test1; by group x; run;

          data keep_first;
          set test1;
          by group x;
          if first.group or first.x;
          run;

          proc sql;
          create table final
          as
          select a.group, a.x, a.y, b.z
          from test a
          left join keep_first b
          on a.group=b.group
          and a.x=b.x
          order by a.group, a.y, a.x;
          quit;






          share|improve this answer












          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer










          answered Nov 9 at 22:27









          Rhythm

          635




          635











          • There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
            – Richard
            Nov 9 at 22:33










          • yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
            – Rhythm
            Nov 9 at 22:34










          • Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
            – Richard
            Nov 10 at 1:06










          • Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:10










          • Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:07
















          • There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
            – Richard
            Nov 9 at 22:33










          • yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
            – Rhythm
            Nov 9 at 22:34










          • Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
            – Richard
            Nov 10 at 1:06










          • Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 15:10










          • Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
            – stunt
            Nov 11 at 21:07















          There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
          – Richard
          Nov 9 at 22:33




          There are no x and y in your first step's datalines.
          – Richard
          Nov 9 at 22:33












          yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
          – Rhythm
          Nov 9 at 22:34




          yes .. there are .. 1060011 "10600 1 1" I didn't mention any spaces , so my informat also read 5., 1., 1.
          – Rhythm
          Nov 9 at 22:34












          Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
          – Richard
          Nov 10 at 1:06




          Ah, see it now, old eyes. Apologies
          – Richard
          Nov 10 at 1:06












          Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 15:10




          Thanks for you response. How do I maintain (or bring back) other variables in the dataset apart from group, x, y &z?
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 15:10












          Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 21:07




          Ok thanks for this interesting approach using sql to create a table and ten left join. works. Thank you!
          – stunt
          Nov 11 at 21:07

















           

          draft saved


          draft discarded















































           


          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53230571%2fcreating-same-values-within-a-group-using-retain-statement-in-sas%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown





















































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown

































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown







          Popular posts from this blog

          How to how show current date and time by default on contact form 7 in WordPress without taking input from user in datetimepicker

          Syphilis

          Darth Vader #20