Rules:

Battle happens in an indestructible planet. No BFR. Morals off. Perfect teamwork. Kyle Rayner is at standard pre-new 52 levels. Silver Surfer is at post-Annihilation levels. Thor is Worthy. Who wins?

Kyle and Surfer combo is too deadly

Quasar is the only one who can stand up to either of them, but he probably loses to both and he definitely can't beat both. Black Bolt and Thor get borderline fodderized

Duo.

GL and SS.

I’m gonna go against the grain and say the Team wins 6/10.

I think it’s an honestly fair assessment to say that if two opponents go against Kyle while one distracts Surfer, the two will be able to beat Kyle before Surfer beats whoever his opponent is.

Quasar has shown to be on a level at least comparable to Surfer, Surfer and Thor have fought to a standstill on several occassions (IIRC Thor has even had the upper hand a couple of times), and BB has done as well against certain opponents that Surfer also fought (e.g. Hulk, Thanos, etc.)

I see no reason why the Team can’t come out on top for a majority once it’s three of them against just Surfer. If two go up against Surfer while one goes up against Kyle, I dunno how that would go. That’s trickier.

I can back the trio. Quasar and Surfer are about equals, with Surfer edging it out. Kyle is superior to Thor by a bit, but if Black Bolt can support Quasar. They can defiantly take out Surfer. It really all depends on how long Thor lasts.

Duo.

Trio.

Norrin solos

Trio.

The duo wins.

Team 1.