Questions about inconsistencies I found in star wars legends
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Questions about inconsistencies I found in star wars legends
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
Wiki
- Characters
- Creators
- Teams
- Volumes
- Issues
- Publishers
- Locations
- Concepts
- Things
- Story Arcs
- Movies
- Series
- Episodes
- Characters
- Creators
- Teams
- Volumes
- Issues
- Publishers
- Locations
- Concepts
- Things
- Story Arcs
- Movies
- Series
- Episodes
Forums
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Community
- Top Users
- Activity Feed
- User Lists
- Community Promos
- Top Users
- Activity Feed
- User Lists
- Community Promos
Archives
- News
- Reviews
- Videos
- Podcasts
- Previews
- News
- Reviews
- Videos
- Podcasts
- Previews
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Questions about inconsistencies I found in star wars legends
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Questions about inconsistencies I found in star wars legends
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
#1
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 8 hours ago
- Show Bio
I have recently been reading into star wars legends and noticed many contradictions and would like to know if theres anyway to reconcile these contradicting sources.
One inconsistency I found is between the 2003 clone wars TV series and a labyrinth of evil. In the 2003 clone wars TV series it showcases mace windu force crushing general grievous' chest prior to the space battle over coruscant. The no such even occurs in the novel Labyrinth Of Evil, which served as a prequel to rots and depicted the same events surrounding palpatines capture.(I'm aware that the 2003 series came out before labyrinth but I want to know if the difference in events depicted by the two sources can some how fit into a single continuity)
Another inconsistency I found was between the the 2008 star wars the clone wars TV series, and the novel Dark Lord:The Rise Of Darth Vader. In the clone wars TV series it is explained that the clones have chips inside them that, upon activation force them to kill the jedi. It shows that the clones have no way in whether they want to kill the jedi or not. In Dark Lord: The Rise Of Darth Vader, a squad of clone troopers deliberately disobey order 66 because they thought it was unreasonable. Shouldn't they be incapable of doing so considering the chips?(I'm aware that dark lord came out before the clone wars but I'm wondering if the inconsistency can actually be explained)
So I ask a star wars legends expert to explain to me if there are any ways to reconcile these inconsistencies. Is there any explanation to these inconsistencies, and a way that the events depicted in the sources could fall into a single continuity, or are they just inconsistencies?
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
- TheVivas
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18463
Wiki Points: 56741
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
#2
Posted by
TheVivas
(18463 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@hellothere111: The first one is just an inconsistency. I’ll have to read LoE again to make sure.
The second one is due to the 2008 CW series basically going through and retelling events in the Clone Wars. That was never meant to mesh with the older Legends material, which is one of the reasons that made the switch between Canon and Legends.
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
#3
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
@thevivas: I see. So basically both are just inconsistencies that can't be reconciled to fit into a single continuity
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- HelloThere111
- Follow
Forum Posts: 42
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
#4
Posted by
HelloThere111
(42 posts)
- 28 days, 7 hours ago
- Show Bio
But I will wait for other people to respond
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Please Log In to post.
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Forums
Main boards
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Popular wiki boards
- X-Men
- Spider-Man
- Dick Grayson
- Batman
- Wonder Woman
- Teen Titans
- Cyclops
- Superman
- Hulk
- Storm
Top posters
Kairan1979
17841 posts
RIKR2
14861 posts
Xwraith
12777 posts
the_stegman
12455 posts
waezi2
11366 posts
Guru_Crack
10232 posts
StormShadow_X
8995 posts
Battle_Forum_Junkie
8453 posts
RustyRoy
8189 posts
Wolverine008
7782 posts
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Log in to comment
Log in to comment