Battle of the Metal Men.

Fight takes place in Times Square.

Round 1: Morals On.

Round 2: Bloodlusted,

Colossus

Colossus takes both rounds

Colossus should take a slim majority. I think Steel has the most strength but I think Colossus has the best striking power (with Girder in second) and actual fighting skill. I could see this battle favoring Steel a lot more once he gets some more showings and feats.

Colossus is a good fighter. Although Steel gives a good fight. Colossus takes both rounds.

Tempted to say Colossus as he has the most visually impressive combat feats, but in terms of actual strength showings Steel blows him out of the water. Steel wins.

Steel wins. He has a drastic advantage in every category but skill, and that doesn't matter when his strength, durability, and speed blow the other two out of the water.

Either Colossus or Steel win. Girder isn't anything special.

Thought it was Deadpool colossus who should stomp. Give the edge to dofp colossus because to be honest, I don't know steels feats and girder isn't a factor

Steel doesn't have the combat feats to suggest he can win

He was KOed by a small dynamite explosion yet stopped a train in the same episode, so right now he's all over the place

Stopping Train could be a major outlier or the explosion could be who knows

Steel has the best showings..Colossus didn't really do anything in any of the movies.

Steel>Colossus>Girder.

Steel

Steel

Yeah, I think Colossus has a "budget advantage" over Steel - Steel should be striking really powerfully, but I think the TV budget can't really make that clear - all they can really do is have people he punches fly away on cables, while a larger budget film can add a lot more visual weight (and speed) to striking with superior CGI, even though Deadpool didn't even have that massive of a budget. Same thing goes for the DCEU vs. CW/CBS shows - Supergirl's fights involving Superman, MM, etc. look really underwhelming, but it seems as if most of that is just budget limitation.

By strength feats alone, Steel should have better striking than Colossus. Unfortunately, given the medium, I don't think we're going to see much of this.

Colossus wins... both rounds... he has fought 1 on 1 and beaten far stronger foes than either Steel or Girder have..... for example

Juggernaut = https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/powerlisting/images/b/bf/Colossus_vs_Juggernaut.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20170314211308

Thing (fantastic 4) = https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11111/111118857/4215152-2117879876-tumbl.jpg

whole packs of Sentinels = https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_medium/11130/111300304/5810917-image.jpeg

.... I don’t think either Steel or Girder are anywhere near the same level as Colossus in terms of feats of strength and/or general fighting prowess... it could be a very easy battle for colossus in fact... like literally a few swift punches

Now if you were gonna add “Man of Steel John Henry Irons aka Steel (DC) especially the early 52 event version of him” to this little “men of metal” battle equation this would be a totally different ball game.... that DC Steel wins every round without a shadow of a doubt without breaking a sweat... he fights alongside Superman and faces (with great effectiveness) superman level enemies like doomsday, darkseid, brainiac... etc...... so yeh...