• Pre New 52, Worthy Warrior Madness Thor, Post Annihilation Surfer


• Battle on an Indestructible Planet


• Perfect Teamwork


• Start 1000 Feet Away


• NO BFR

Round 1- Morals on

Round 2- Morals off, Bloodlusted

He isn't taking all of them down at the same time, especially with pre-FP versions.

Team stomps, this is a mismatch tbh.

Thor has shown that he can damage Silver Surfer, he has dented his head with a head butt and even KOed him in B+T without the PG. With the other two pounding on Norrin with their equally impressive damage output and using their speed and versatility to give Thor the openings he needs: Surfer gets wrecked.

Surfer gets beaten both rounds.

I'd argue that any of the people on Team 1 can give Surfer a hell of a fight

Team murder stomps

Surfer gets stomped. Rayner is a challenge on his own.

Team stomps.

Silver not that powerful anybody here 1on1 can give him more than just a run for his money

This is too much for Silver Surfer. Superman may go down in the process, though.

Thor probably going to be the MVP hes already fought the surfer(tho surfer was being passive in most of their fights but watev) Thor can surfer a challenge adding some back up secures the win superman may go down tho

Team, Thor himself is a problem.

Surfer was, for the most part, holding back every time he fought Thor...Surfer has beat the shit out of Bill and oneshotted Cancerverse Thor who was supposedly his equal in power.

Team stomps both rounds. Kyle and Superman, on their own would give Surfer a run for his money, Kyle can arguably solo and so can Superman.

first: team will win, trough a tough and bloody fight.

second: Superman solos.

Team overwhelms and defeats Surfer.

Team trounces him.

Big order for Surfer: Thor alone seem to have his number.

@rampagethefirst: Kyle lost to surfer in a cannon cross over if I'm not mistaken and Superman has consistently lost to surfer on comicvine, go to any thread and the general consensus is that Superman loses badly against surfer

OT: Spite, Surfer loses but lol at Superman soloing

@leonardsnart: First off, Kyle has never faced Surfer in a canon crossover ever, none of those Marvel vs DC crossovers are canon and Superman barely loses to Surfer in a one on one, that's why I said he could "arguably" solo, key word; Arguably.

@leonardsnart: That was a fan voted fight.

I am almost positive Kyle and Thor both can solo. This is a stomp.

@brucerogers: I guess I was mistaken

@rampagethefirst: No, Superman doesn't arguably solo, he loses 1 on 1

@leonardsnart: Do you know what arguably means? Literally google the definition of the word lmao. Morals on fight between Surfer and Superman has always come down to equal votes for both opponents.

@rampagethefirst: arguably means an argument can be made, there's no arguement that can be made here, superman loses to surfer

@leonardsnart: There can, and has been made multiple times, as I've said before, a morals off Surfer beats Superman in a tough fight but a morals on Surfer can arguably lose.

@rampagethefirst: In character superman vs in character surfer, superman loses

Morals off superman vs morals off surfer, superman loses badly

Superman only wins if surfer forgets his powers, if that's what you meant by Superman arguably winning then I agree

This is pointless tho because we agree Surfer loses badly here against the team, if you think there's a chance Superman wins against surfer go get slaughtered in a superman vs silver surfer thread

@leonardsnart: Whatever, I can make a case for Superman barely winning against a morals on Surfer.

@rampagethefirst: go make make it and get laughed at

@leonardsnart: I would if I really cared about it, I care about it as much as I care about your opinion on the matter itself.

@rampagethefirst: lol cool story

The team wins.