Rules

• Team 1: Kazdan is as he appears in TFU. Qui-Gon is as he appears in TPM with previous Legends feats applying. Cilghal is in her Legends prime.


• Team 2: Malgus is as he appears in Return. Savage is in his TCW prime with previous Legends feats applying. Bandon is as he appears in KOTOR.


• They start at a 30m distance in the pictured location.


• They fight in character (let's assume that Kazdan is sane enough to understand the principle of team loyalty).

Masters of the Jedi Order: Kazdan Paratus, Qui-Gon Jinn & Cilghal

Dark Apprentices: Malgus, Savage Opress & Darth Bandon

Location

I think team 1 has the advantage. Paratus has crazy force powers, and Jinn's ability to duel TPM Maul means he can at least contend with Savage, who's clearly the MVP of his team. Cilghal seems like her team's weak link, but I'd say she could be argued to be above Bandon (she's noted as being below NJO duelists like Kyp and Kyle, IIRC, but both the masters' duel on Endor and her duel against an insane Jedi show that her title as master is no joke).

Team 1, probably.