Who would you want to work on a Dune film trilogy/saga?
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Who would you want to work on a Dune film trilogy/saga?
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Characters
Creators
Teams
Volumes
Issues
Publishers
Locations
Concepts
Things
Story Arcs
Movies
Series
Episodes
Characters
Creators
Teams
Volumes
Issues
Publishers
Locations
Concepts
Things
Story Arcs
Movies
Series
Episodes
Forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Community
Top Users
Activity Feed
User Lists
Community Promos
Top Users
Activity Feed
User Lists
Community Promos
Archives
News
Reviews
Videos
Podcasts
Previews
News
Reviews
Videos
Podcasts
Previews
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Who would you want to work on a Dune film trilogy/saga?
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Who would you want to work on a Dune film trilogy/saga?
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
#1
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Directors? Actors? ect.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Jonez_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11443
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
#2
Posted by
Jonez_
(11443 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Wow, great idea for a thread.
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- MonsterStomp
- Follow
Forum Posts: 36581
Wiki Points: 361
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
#3
Posted by
MonsterStomp
(36581 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Dune?
Wus dat?
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
#4
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Stanley Kubrick. It would either be amazing or really, really boring.
That being said, there is a Dune movie, and from what I hear it's pretty good. Actually, I have it sitting around my hard drive, think I'll go watch it.
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Emperorb777
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10851
Wiki Points: 1
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
#5
Edited by
Emperorb777
(10851 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
What is dune?
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
#6
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
#7
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
How bananas would it been if this Dune movie got made............
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
#8
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
It is widely considered the pinnacle of Sci Fi writing. A lot of people like to make the comparison that Dune is to Sci Fi as Lord of The Rings is to Fantasy.
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@monsterstomp said:
Dune?
Wus dat?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
@immortal777 said:
What is dune?
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
- Bruxae
- Follow
Forum Posts: 18147
Wiki Points: 11098
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 6
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
#9
Posted by
Bruxae
(18147 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I'd love too, not sure about casting but - it would be awesome to see an updated version.
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
- dagmar_merrill
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12701
Wiki Points: 1547
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 74 Lists: 7
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
#10
Posted by
dagmar_merrill
(12701 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know what Dune is
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
#11
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@judasnixon:
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
#12
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
bump
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Jay0253
- Follow
Forum Posts: 98
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
#13
Posted by
Jay0253
(98 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Joss Whedon, I think would be a good director. He directed Firefly, and did one hell of a job. He's also directed a lot of other stuff like Avengers. As for actors, no clue.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
#14
Edited by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Ridley Scott comes to mind for me. He is supposedly going to make a Forever War movie in the near future. It may be a good indicator if he is up to the task.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
#15
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Vincent D'Onofrio as The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.......
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Detrolord
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3198
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
#16
Posted by
Detrolord
(3198 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Hmm not sure but don't make it like Starship Troopers
and we and a complete remake to true the book of SST
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Crom-Cruach
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8935
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
#17
Posted by
Crom-Cruach
(8935 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Maybe Guillermo Del Toro.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
- deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8662
Wiki Points: 2294
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 100 Lists: 6
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
#18
Posted by
deactivated-5a162dd41dd64
(8662 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I watched the movie. It's not very good.
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
#19
Edited by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Kit Harington as Paul Atreides...... For the ladies....
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- RD189
- Follow
Forum Posts: 3110
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
#20
Posted by
RD189
(3110 posts)
- 4 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
It would have to be like, David Cronenberg or Del Torro to direct, or even Riddley Scott, someone really out there as far as style.
As for casting, don't really matter. Sting played Leto Atriedes for god's sake. There ya go, Gene Simmons as Leto in Dune 2014
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
#21
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Bump
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
- judasnixon
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12663
Wiki Points: 699
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 4
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
#22
Posted by
judasnixon
(12663 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
My go to director right now is that cat who directed the Battle of the Bastards episode from Game of Thrones... I want to see him work with a bigger budget, and different genres of film....
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
- jumpstart55
- Follow
Forum Posts: 11025
Wiki Points: 268
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 14
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
#23
Posted by
jumpstart55
(11025 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
George Miller as the Director.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Silverrings
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5452
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
#24
Edited by
Silverrings
(5452 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
From what i've seen of it, Jodorowsky :P Otherwise, maybe Tarsem Singh, David Fincher, Alex Proyas or Park Chan Wook, ignoring whether or not they'd want to do it or if a studio would risk big money on any of them. They each have very different cinematic talents and a shared ability to create similarly dark, stylish and emotional films that juggle much more abrasive subjects than most directors, from violence through sexuality to sanity. If any of them wanted to do it and had a serious budget to work with they could smash it.
As for actors, possibly Chris Evans as Paul, Maisie Williams as Alia, Ian McShane as Leto, Idris Elba as Gurney, Gary Oldman as Duncan, Viggo Mortensen as Liet, Chiwetel Ejiofor as Stilgar, Emily Blunt as Chani, Tom Hardy as Feyd, as Baron Harkonnen and Ian McKellen as Shaddam. That's just a quick google-boosted crack at it, largely for fun, i can totally see other people in all these roles.
I should say that i'm a guy who loves what he knows of Dune, but i haven't read the books yet (i really want to). I've seen the film, which was a bit of a task, but an interesting one, and some of the mini-series, and i'm perfectly fine with adaptive changes being made where ever necessary/artistically worthwhile, so i'd be cool with changing ages and colours of characters for the sake of good actors playing them.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
#25
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
Man, you've been thinking about this for 2 years. You must have the whole cast and crew pinned down by now. :P
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
@bumpyboo said:
This is a very cool question, gonna give it some thought and come back to it :)
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- AlphaQ
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5959
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
#26
Posted by
AlphaQ
(5959 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
I don't know shit about directors :(
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
- BumpyBoo
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14526
Wiki Points: 270187
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 10 Lists: 20
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
#27
Posted by
BumpyBoo
(14526 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_: Lmao, fair point. Am out atm, will take a look at this tonight XD
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
#28
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
Cuarón
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
- Jonny_Anonymous
- Follow
Forum Posts: 45774
Wiki Points: 11109
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 3 Lists: 32
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
#30
Posted by
Jonny_Anonymous
(45774 posts)
- 2 years, 5 months ago
- Show Bio
The sad truth is that Dune is a movie that can't, or more specifically shouldn't be made. The themes and concepts of politics, sex, religion, philosophy, spirituality and sociality run too deep in a book like Dune for it to be made accurately in to movie. In this day and age where everything needs to be a family friendly movie with a big budget that gets a big return there is no way a studio would put up the cash required to make something as weird and experimental as Dune. The only way it would happen is if the studios just turned it in to a generic sci-fi movie but that is something that should never ever happen, Dune is NOT Star Wars, it is NOT Star Trek it's not even Lord of the Rings. Jodorowsky's Dune is on paper at least pretty much the perfect adaption of what that world could be but it is also an impossible movie to make.
However there have been a few people who have been interested in making an animated Dune adaptation and I could totally see that working. Jodorowsky said he wanted some one to take his storyboard and make an animated movie out of it and Matt Rhodes, the guy who does that art for Dragon Age did some Dune art. Get Del Toro on board maybe get Michael Kirkbride to write it and get an animated show on Netflix.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- _Gaff_
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5104
Wiki Points: 5771
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
#31
Posted by
_Gaff_
(5104 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- PayneInTheAss
- Follow
Forum Posts: 10809
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
#32
Posted by
PayneInTheAss
(10809 posts)
- 4 months, 22 days ago
- Show Bio
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
Just now? It´s been a while
Anyway, it´s awesome. Only thing lacking is Johan Johansson in the score
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
@_gaff_ said:
Just found out Denis Villeneuve is going to direct 2 Dune movies. What do people think? I personally like his sci-fi credentials, so I am remaining positive.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Off-Topic
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Please Log In to post.
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Forums
Main boards
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Popular wiki boards
- X-Men
- Storm
- Spider-Man
- Dragon Ball Universe
- Hulk
- Thanos
- Wonder Woman
- Superman
- Star Wars Universe
- Jean Grey
Top posters
Rouflex
31884 posts
PowerHerc
27706 posts
Dragonborn_CT
24999 posts
Pharoh_Atem
24504 posts
King Saturn
23566 posts
Xwraith
20635 posts
Straight-Fire
20453 posts
Deadite
19243 posts
Wolverine008
18486 posts
Helloman
18280 posts
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Log in to comment
Log in to comment