Rules:

Battle happens in an indestructible planet. No BFR. Everyone is bloodlusted. Perfect teamwork. Silver Surfer is at post-Annihilation levels. Thor is Worthy. All DC characters are at standard pre-new 52 levels (no Fernus). Who wins?

ROUND 1: No telepathy.

ROUND 2: Telepathy is allowed.

Lanterns can take a slight majority in round 1, not sure about 2.

Team 1 both rounds

Team 1 Guy, John, and Kilowog are not that strong and can be taken by Thor+Superman. MMH holds off or beats Hal, Surfer beats/holds off Kyle

team 1

Bump

I’m pretty sure team 1 takes this pretty easily

Team 1.

Round 1: Very close fight, could go either way. Superman can be taken out with Kryptonite constructs, but he has speed and raw power on his side. MMH can be dealt with. But Surfer is a problem. However, Thor is a weak link and the fight will quickly become 3 v 5.

Round 2: Team 1 wins, Surfer is MVP. Thor still goes down first, but TP gives Team 1 the edge it needs to deal with the bloodlusted lanterns. While the Lanterns can defend against top-tier TP attacks, they have to focus on it.

I think Team 1 can pull it off in both rounds. Silver Surfer can likely take on the two weakest lanterns of the bunch. (Guy Gardener and Kilowog). While the others can each account for one lantern.