Combatants

Location: Mexico

Rules:

First off, god bless our military. Usually when it comes to the #1 special force in america its the SEALS who gain more recognition but the Berets are very great and tactical in their own way. Who would win out 5v5 from these elite commandos?

• Both have been given orders to take each other out by any means


• Both have sufficient ammo to last for a long battle


• No HQ contact. Just tossed into battle


• Both have 1 call and 1 call only for an air support attack


• Must locate each other. Dont have a fix on eachothers radar nor can they recon


• No time limit


• Standard equipment for both teams

Berets. Navy seals are trained for quick in and out scenarios were the berets will be deployed and actually stay to fight. Berets win with high difficulty.

Bump. I know these battles dont get too much attention since they arent fictional but I just wanted to get some opinions about it.

@destinyman75 How would you think this battle will turn out?

SEALs are trained for any scenario.. It can go either way but I got the seals taking it.

Is the city populated? If so I'd give it to the seals mid difficulty. If not and it relies more so on conventional tactics than im favoring the berets.

GB. Seals are prep experts.

Not sure how much of a difference it would make for scenario 1 but Ill go ahead and throw in 100 civilians populated in the whole city instead of your average population you would get in a place like that. Somewhat better?

This should be a pretty even fight. But what would you consider standard gear for each side? I feel they both use the same or very similar weapons based on what their mission requires.

@proteusxmanrxis: Me and my fellow Marines would own them both lol but as to this scenario I'll say this. Can go either way.

Seals are better at seek and destroy which gives them a clear advantage here.

The GB's however are trained to hold a position better (though both are experts). So I see the seals finding the GB's before the GB's find them. Having said that, I see at least one GB going down in an ambush. We can say two go down. The other three GB's however are then going to dig in and give them hell. A GB can hold out well. The seals being more if a strike force will press the attack, to me this means a couple are going to go down. To me this means 3 seals get cut down while moving in. 2-3 thus far. This is where it gets tricky, as any number of things can happen. I'd the seals continue to press the attack (which I see as more then likely, then I see the GB's coming out on top after one more loss. 2-2 again gets harder. The seals aren't stupid and will likely try to flank even more and find a way to flush the GB's out. If they say toss a grenade, or use a smoke bomb to cover there advance they should succed. However if the GB's anticipate this they will pull back and set an ambush loosing one more member. So goes either, the seals press flush out and win, or the GB:s anticipate and set a trap and win (via crossfire more then likely). Other then these two scenarios I can't call it for certain.

In all honesty it’s pretty hard to tell

Seals are more trained for sneak attack purposes and ambushes that’s their bread and butter so if they get a good ambush then they should take this but if the GB are able to anticipate this or if this would just be a full on fight with each other they should be the ones to come out on top

Though it would really all depend on the people if they’re going to win or not how smart the person is how tactical they are how strong they are how to utilize their weapon to the utmost effectiveness or would really depend on the actual people fighting rather than the troops themselves

Pretty sure the Seals get better funding and equipment. Might be talking out of my ass though...

The biggest...absolute biggest deciding factor in this fight is the air support call. The navy/marine corps team air support>>>>>>>>>anything the army can call in. Especially for this kind of fight.

The Navy has batter close air support by far and the Navy has fast movers. SEALS win...although I would argue that the green berets are not nearly as well prepared for heads up battle as the seals are. The green berets are long term operators, whose mission is quite often suopport and training. The SEALS are just too fast and too accurate for anybody really to hold out against them.

-

-

-

Except for a Marine Corps Rifle squad. Hoorah.

@destinyman75 Thank you for your service.

OT: This is a really tough one to call. My knowledge on both the teams are average but still fail in comparison to many other guys on here. To my best bet, I will have to go with the SEAL's.

So they will ruin a city with air support just to kill 5 person? Genius. But if seals play it smart and having prep in their belt they'll win but if greens outsmart them they'll win.