Both characters were good on their respected movies, i liked Rorschach's voice on that movie but i would prefer Ledger for better for portraying perfectly as Joker

Joker.

Jackie gave the most comic accurate portrayal. Like, there's no one who could get the character as well as he did. Ledger on the other hand wasn't really that accurate to the comics, but innovated so much in terms of acting and mannerisms that he was able to not only make something new, but pretty much set a standard that very few have been able to match, let alone do better.

I don't think you can pick a better performance. Both of them did what they were asked to do perfectly.

Heath Ledger, but I agree that Jackie Earle Haley gave a great performance as Rorschach.

I don’t think Hayley was on that level. He earned a place among the elites, he gave an unbelievable performance, but Ledger’s Joker is still separated from all the rest.

Bump

Ledger’s joker actually influenced DC comics and other media in terms of the joker.

Joker.

Put the two in the same movie and Joker would be the standout. Both 10/10’s tho.

Rorschach because his performance is just right, in my opinion

Ledger practically stole the show disproportionately which kinda made Batman's performance pretty underwhelming (his ridiculous voice didn't help either) and ruined the film for me.

Ledger. Wasn’t as source material accurate as Haley’s, but it was stronger imo