valkyrie

I gotta go with Heimdall

Valkyrie

What are you all's reasons?

They both have shown to be able to take down ships alone, what has Valkyrie done that Heimdall can't do?

Idk, both are skilled Asgardians with a sword. Heimdall seems to have a more powerful sword, but Valkyrie might have the skill edge. Not sure.

Good match, I would probably go with Valkyrie. She has better feats beating Loki, sparring with Hulk. Other than that they are pretty even.

Valkeryie is more skilled by statements. But Heimdal is underrated.

Heimdall seems more trained and accomplished in fighting skills. Heimdall imo

Valk by feats an skill. Ragnarok act 3 is very telling of this.

Heimdall, good fight though.

Heimdall and it's not even close.

"You have great power, Heimdall. Did Odin ever fear you?"

"No."

"And why is that?"

"Because he is my King. And I’m sworn to obey him."

Loki and Heimdall

Anyone powerful enough to be a rival/threat to Odin is clearly out of Valkyrie's reach.

Val

I think we can all agree they are both badass.

I don't think either has really done anything I can't picture the other doing. Maybe Heimdall surviving and escaping from the power of the Casket of Ancient Winters, but that's sort of unquantifiable. In general though, Heimdall does seem like a higher tier of Asgardian to me. A few of the statements made about him, his status as the gate-keeper of Asgard as well as the fact that Thor, Odin and Heimdall seem to be the only Asgardians with inherent Godlike powers on top of their Asgardian physiology make me think he'd probably win.

I'd give it to Valkyrie.

Heimdall.

The Valkyrie is way more impressive.

If I remember correctly in Ragnarok Heimdall was having some trouble with Hela's forces while Valkyrie was effortlessly stomping them.

I guess they nerfed him in the movie but still.

Heimdall by statements and his post as gatekeeper

Hiemdall wins by his Gatekeeping Force

Heimdall is more powerful.

I'm riding for Heimdall.

Valkyrie has better feats

Valk should win this.

@richubs: His goal was to protect the civilians. He can’t go all out with no one to defend them

@miekskywalker: Oh right sorry I thought it was some other thread.

I know he can't go all out but he was getting trouble from 2 of them which shouldn't happen. He doesn't need to go all out for 2 of them

Valkyrie.

Valkyrie.

Valkyrie wins.