All in street clothes

Ras, Ollie and Stick are all armed with swords

Cap has his shield

Team 1 in a very tough fight, Stick is a weak link.

Why is Stick a weak link against swordsmen? Wouldn't he be more suited to counter Ra's or Oliver than Cap would?

They can all one-shot each other if they land a clean shot, the swordsmen with their swords, and Cap with his shield. The difference is that the shield provides much better protection as well, and that combined with Cap's strength and resistance to team 1's blunt force attacks, and he becomes the most powerful player. Stick, on the other hand, is worse than Oliver in every way, and Ra's outclasses him in skill.

This can really go both ways.

Team 1 wins in a good fight.

Ra's can take down Cap through raw speed and skill with a blade, and the blade will also mean that Cap's physicals will be less of an issue (durability and strength become irrelevent outside of possible shield blocks from Cap). He can dance around the shield and land hits with the sword.

Oliver definitely takes down Stick in a sword fight, he's more skilled and much better physically.

Ras solos, what is this?

Stick is on the same tier as Oliver and Ra's in sword fighting imo. He holds one of them off.

The other one can probably beat Cap.

Team MCU stomps.

Stick beat Black sky twice. He can definitely at the very least hold his own or most likely beat either one. Cap stomps whoever he faces.

@thehunter: Not Ras. Maybe Oliver though.

Why would Oliver be better than Ra's at sword fighting?

@thehunter: He meant that he might be on Oliver's level but not Ra's.

Steve easily has the best weapon here, he can potentially solo. Giving him Stick makes this even worse

Same shit all over again. Cap's a weak link.

Why?

Becasue he has never fought a proper swordsmen?

I still think Steve will give some trouble. In his defensive mode with his shield he'll be tough to tag.

@tonymartial: It's not a mismatch or anything, but Stick is certainly more suited to fight Ra's or Oliver.

@payneintheass: Because of multiple reasons. Both on team 1 are faster than Cap, have better reach and are far more skilled. Not to mention, even one hit from either is going to seriously injure him.

@rbt: Eh you are probably right, I just can´t make my mind around the whole sword vs shield thing.

And I don´t think Cap´s a weak link either. Not at all.

The MCU team wins.

I don't know how Steve vs Ra's would go. I could make a case for either, Ra's has a reach advantage and probably a skill edge, but Steve only needs to grab the sword once and it's over, and his fight with Panther puts him around the same level of fighting ability considering the latter has feats on par with Ra's best skill showing (his training session). If I had to choose I'd go with Rogers.

Stick beats Oliver. His showing against the Black Sky is more than enough. Her enhansed speed is pretty much the only reason she won that exchange IMO.

I think Stick is more fit to fight here than Steve.

Ra's can absolutely take Steve, he's faster, has a reach advantage, and is massively more skilled. Oliver vs. Stick would be a solid fight, but overall I'd give it to Ollie, he certainly is physically superior in every aspect by a decent margin, and he should be slightly more skill given his performance against Ra's and then his improvement in later seasons.