Gimli gets his axe,Thorin gets Orcrist.

They start 10 feet apart in a open field both are bloodlusted.

Win by death.

Thorin owns, did you see how badass and sexy he was when he stood up to the Pale Orc? I mean he got tossed around after the stare down, but yunno...

Gimli

Thorin, he's far more agile with orcrist and would kill gimli without him even landing a blow

bump

Maybe Thorin.

Isn't Gimli like the mightiest Dwarf ever?

gimli seemed to handle fodder better than thoring, but we dont get to see him fight anyone noteworthy 1on1 in the movies. I havent read the books so I dunno if theres anything from it. I would say gimli though

Thorin

Thorin in a food fight.

Gimli's fodder = Uruk-Hai. Thorin's fodder = regular orcs.

Gimli 8/10.

Let's just think about this: Gimli was graced by Gladriel herself AND was licensed to pass into the West. That's kind of a big deal. Not that his reputation would earn him a victory in battle, but it's an important peripheral note.

I think Gimli's warrior-like faction has been demonstrated more than Thorin's ever was. Thorin had a more notable story by slaying Azog, but Gimli bested Legolas—a godamn Elven prince warrior badass—by one in a Uruk-slay count (43 to 42). Uruks are formidably tougher, stronger, and smarter than the goblins that Thorin fought. We should note that Azog may have been over-rated in the theatrical adaption to his character, too.

both killed fodders. thorin however has fought and slain an actual notable strong and skilled opponent (azog). as for the uruk argument, its mentioned that the dol guldur orcs were bred for war too.

If it is the movie version, Thorin is very OP and seems to effortlessly kill orcs (mainly down to bad directing) if its the book Gimli fought in way more battles and survived unlike Thorin. So book version Gimli takes it. I think the Uruk-hai are superior to the orcs in the hobbit because they are newer and smarter. Most the orcs in the hobbit are dumb misty mountain orcs, that's why they die so easily I think. Uruk-Hai and mordor orcs are actually a challenge.

Well, Gimli survived, and kicked a ton of ass through the battle of Helms Deep, the siege of Parimor (if that's spelled right) and plenty of skirmishes. Thorin DID survive Smaug, indirectly, and some decent skirmishes, but died in single combat (true he killed his enemy too)

Given their success record)

Gimli takes this and then goes and gets out drunk by Legolas later.

Honestly they both kick ass but I think Thorin has this. He was able to fight perfectly fine after not sleeping and eating for days during the gold sickness in BOFA.

Plus at 53 he was able to damage Azog and survive which is impressive.

Book versions? Gimli slaughters.

Movie versions? Thorin wins in a good fight.

Gimli

thorin. he has the benefit of actually fighting another skilled foe. all gimli has killed is fodder orcs

Book versions: Gimli pretty much stomps.

Movie versions: Could go either way. Yes, Thorin killed Azog, But he wasn't that impressive, Plus, the Hobbit orcs were stupid and bad trained as hell compared to Uruk-hai. At least Gimli survived his battles :v

I say Gimli 6/10 just because I like him more.

Btw, The Hobbit was a crappy movie.

Gimli takes the majority. Although Thorin is a skilled warrior, in my opinion Gimli has been in a few more Battles with much higher stakes . And Gimli never seems to show weakness.

Gimli. Aragorn said that Gimli is the best axe user he has ever seen. It means a lot honestly. He has ~80 years of experience and training from the elves.

Movie versions- Thorin wins in a hard fight. Gimli was impressive but Thorin? He was dwarf version of Aragorn in that movie. He displayed a lot more acrobatics, skill and strenght in his combat... probably technical issues played a role too - because the actor is much younger, but he still wrecks by feats and logic.

Books versions and composite - Gimli lolstomps. Aragorn confirmed Gimli was the most skilled dwarf warrior he's ever seen, and Aragorn has seen a lot. His battle feats like cutting down dozens of orc heads in every encounter beat anything Thorin has ever done and were impressive to everyone, including treebeard. Not to mention his stamina is legendary, he was able to keep up with elf and numenorian ranger (who basically have near unlimited stamina) in running 3 days non-stop with no rest or sleep, (and with impressive speed, since they covered more distance than horse riders were said to be able to achieve in the same time) and with his shorter legs he had to make twice their effort. Gimli is confirmed the most powerful dwarf warrior in the lore book-wise. Thorin doesn't even come close.

Lol the thorin wank is real...

Gimli was portrayed 10× stronger than the dwarfs in the hobbit trilogy; who are pretty much treated like children.

Better gear or not, gimli would knock thorin back easily if their weapons ever clashed

Gimli wins.

Gimli stomps him.

Book versions: Gimli stomps Thorin with ease.

Movie versions: This would definitely be a closer fight, Thorin was able to fight off 100 goblin mercenaries with Dwalin but Gimli killed a warg by himself whereas Thorin got his ass kicked by Azog on his warg. Plus Gimli was able to kill numerous Uruk Hai which were better armed and stronger than orcs and goblins. So Gimli should take the edge.

Gimli seemed more impressive to me