Battle takes place in New York.

City is deserted.

Random encounter.

BFR not allowed.

Origional Juggernaut.

No prep.

Victory only by knock out or kill.

Who wins?

Superman gets wrecked.

Yeah hes not putting down Juggy, especially New 52 Superman can't... I say this is a spite.

Ez fight for Cain Marko.

What can Marko do against someone strong enough to bench the planet for a week???

I would have said superman due to bfr but thats not the case in this battle.

Superman can't meet the win condition.

Heat vision melts juggs or freeze him then burst him. Juggs not tagging someone who's MFLT+

Heavily in favour of Juggernaut, why make threads when you're going to stack the odds against one of the characters?

Juggs

Juggernaut easily

Punch them until they're either ko'd or killed since it's not a planet holding competition.

Even if BFR is allowed, Cain would still take a large majority.

I want to say superman, but i just don't know.

@hellionvulcan: your right him holding the earth for a week means he punches with the might of a school girl. Seriously regardless of what sort of contest it is I haven’t seen juggernaut perform a strength feat anywhere close to that or survive similar amounts of force, and if that’s the case then it’s also implied that Superman can also hit harder meaning the only person getting ko’d from repeated hits is juggernaut

superman easily

Juggernaut has survived getting his power stripped from him and being turned into a skeleton and surviving, tanking Thor's god blast, Punching over an 8.5 (IIRC) on the richter scale,Sinking down into the earth and shifting the tectonic plates etc as he has numerous feats that easily place him around and above Superman's level. Knocking out Juggernaut with physical force isn't going to happen as Skaar used his old power to punch Juggernaut out of our orbit and it never harmed him nor ko'd him as Juggs can tank everything Superman throws at him.

Supes

Probably Juggernaut eventually.

@hellionvulcan: having trouble finding this tectonic plate feat. Even so moving a tectonic plate is not > holding the earths weight for a week, mind you Clark was drained and could have kept going. Superman’s punches can be felt from the center of the earth to the watchtower in space. Not sure if the same can be said for Skaar. Even so Skaar has great strength sure but he can’t speed blitz and I don’t see feats of Cain withstanding blows like that thousands of times over and Clark would be able to figure out Cain’s ability to gain momentum and exploit it to his advantage like most people who fight him do

Seems i don't have it uploaded but it's in Amazing Spider-Man 627-629, Cain is a lot more powerful now as in the new Thor comic Odinson got in one hit grabbed the item he was after and fled;no one on Clark's level has physically ko'd Juggernaut IIRC plus Juggernaut inertia shield will dead stop Superman any way.

Without BFR Juggy beats him up

Whoever wins, it will certainly hurt in the morning...

Seriously, both are perfectly capable of hanging with each other. Sure, Juggs has a solid edge in durability and damage soak, but Clark is no slouch, strength-wise, Superman has the clear advantage, and a huge advantage in speed and versatility in general. It could go either way, because I really not see Juggs putting Supes down fast, as I can't see Superman putting Juggs fast either.

I mean, given that Clark physically can't hurt Juggernaut (and even if he could there wouldn't be any lasting damage), that's unlikely.

Stalemate

Juggernaut wins.

Let's see: Juggernaut starts stronger than WWH, he has force field that can take Thor's hammer strikes and godblast without damage him, he has healing factor that can make him heal from the bones in case he get damaged, he may be slower than Clark but he can hit characters as fast as Clark eventually and since BFR is not allowed nothing that Superman could do will be a problem for Cain. Juggernaut wins this easily. Maybe in a long fight, but in a secure fight. DC fans still didn't prove how Clark could win that fight.

@pipxeroth: Sure