Disneys Animated movies: 2D or CGI
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Disneys Animated movies: 2D or CGI
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
- Characters
- Creators
- Teams
- Volumes
- Issues
- Publishers
- Locations
- Concepts
- Things
- Story Arcs
- Movies
- Series
- Episodes
- Characters
- Creators
- Teams
- Volumes
- Issues
- Publishers
- Locations
- Concepts
- Things
- Story Arcs
- Movies
- Series
- Episodes
Forums
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Community
- Top Users
- User Lists
- Community Promos
- Top Users
- User Lists
- Community Promos
Archives
- News
- Reviews
- Videos
- Podcasts
- Previews
- News
- Reviews
- Videos
- Podcasts
- Previews
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
Wiki
Arcs
Characters
Companies
Concepts
Issues
Locations
Movies
People
Teams
Things
Volumes
Series
Episodes
Editorial
Videos
Articles
Reviews
Features
Community
Users
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Disneys Animated movies: 2D or CGI
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Please Log In to post.
×
Move topic to another board
Pick a board and hit submit
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Close
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
#1
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Sinse Disney has been focusing on CGI movies these days, what movies did you like better, The 2d traditional hand drawn animation or the CGI movies. What style was you'er most prefered animation.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4972
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
#2
Edited by
deactivated-5bb6a6f86dc65
(4972 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Going to be honest, I prefer most of the characters (especially the animals, they looked gorgeous in the 2016 Jungle Book movie) and scenery to be computer-generated as it looks nicer, but 2D holds a special place in my heart due to nostalgia.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
#3
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
I greatly prefer CGI.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
- PenguinDust
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8778
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 2
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
#4
Edited by
PenguinDust
(8778 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
It's hard to choose. CGI is the current and future of Disney animation, but some of my very favorite Disney movies are traditional cel-animation. Of my Top-5 Disney animated movies, only two are CGI, however they are my number one and number two. Having said this, though what it really comes down to is the story and characters. Several of the Pixar sequels range from mediocre to horrible, so a good film requires more than just spiffy graphics and CGI won't save a bad film from continuing to be bad (I'm looking at you, Transformers franchise!) Today, CG is used in traditional 2D animation, so it's harder to separate the two artforms, as well. What I want most of all is for an animated film or film short to entertain, and maybe even move me a bit.
And while we're on the subject, let's not forget how great a good stop-motion animated movie can look.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- FullMetalEmprah
- Follow
Forum Posts: 4157
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
#5
Edited by
FullMetalEmprah
(4157 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
Honestly both are pretty good, kind of hard to choose. I think I have to go 2D since I prefer Pixar when it comes to CGI.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- DevisedDream
- Follow
Forum Posts: 556
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
#6
Posted by
DevisedDream
(556 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
They are both very good, but I do prefer the 2D style more, personally.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
#7
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 16 days ago
- Show Bio
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
#8
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- deathstroke512
- Follow
Forum Posts: 2375
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
#9
Edited by
deathstroke512
(2375 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D for me
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Fabricolage
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1894
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
#10
Edited by
Fabricolage
(1894 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Never saw the Jungle Book or Moana, but maybe 2D for me so far since more cartoonish effects can be played out. The 3d could be good for the non-cartoon parts I guess.
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Arc_Conductor
- Follow
Forum Posts: 236
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
#11
Posted by
Arc_Conductor
(236 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn: Disney proper not Pixar right?
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- infantfinite128
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5751
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
#12
Posted by
infantfinite128
(5751 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
It's a shame!
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
@hyperfinn said:
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
Disneys recent CGI movies are so clean and way too politically correct.
@infantfinite128 said:
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
2D. I don't like the uncanny valley from the 3D animation.
Plus, I think hand-drawn animation can be quite beautiful.
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
- Batvibe12
- Follow
Forum Posts: 5603
Wiki Points: 586
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 1
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
#13
Posted by
Batvibe12
(5603 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
Both, but if I had to choose, 2D.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Quinlan58
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1677
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
#14
Posted by
Quinlan58
(1677 posts)
- 6 months, 15 days ago
- Show Bio
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
#15
Posted by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 6 months, 22 hours ago
- Show Bio
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
The 2D movies will always be the best, the CGI movies are so clean and bland.
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
@quinlan58 said:
2D, since most of my favorites are still those. This is very likely to change as Disney releases more 3D films, though.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
- Jgames
- Follow
Forum Posts: 8101
Wiki Points: 313
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 1 Lists: 5
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
#16
Edited by
Jgames
(8101 posts)
- 6 months, 21 hours ago
- Show Bio
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- hyperfinn
- Follow
Forum Posts: 1664
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
#17
Edited by
hyperfinn
(1664 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
Classic 2D Disney movies were not afraid to have death and dark themes. these days the politically correct clean CGI movies try too hard to copy Dreamworks movies.
@jgames said:
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
2d since in twenty years I will look back and see that the cgi animation has not hold up. While the 2d animation already stood the test of time. Also not including pixar animation.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- LEGACY6364
- Follow
Forum Posts: 7441
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
#18
Posted by
LEGACY6364
(7441 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
2D by far.
Disney's 2D Animation films are also more mature and less politically correct.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- mrmonster
- Follow
Forum Posts: 14791
Wiki Points: 0
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
#19
Posted by
mrmonster
(14791 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Even though CGI animation is much better, I think the movies themselves were better back in the days of 2D. The only true masterpiece they've made since transitioning to CGI is Zootopia. Big Hero 6 and Wreck it Ralph were pretty good, Moana was okay, Frozen and Tangled were just bad.
They had several masterpieces back in their 2D days; The Lion King, Aladdin, Hercules, The Little Mermaid, etc.
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- Kevd4wg
- Follow
Forum Posts: 12539
Wiki Points: 266
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
#20
Posted by
Kevd4wg
(12539 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Depends on the film, but I do feel that 2D animation has more possibilités then CGI
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
- ANTHP2000
- Follow
Forum Posts: 26077
Wiki Points: 150
Followed by: 0
Reviews: 0 Lists: 0
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
#21
Posted by
ANTHP2000
(26077 posts)
- 5 months, 30 days ago
- Show Bio
Both have had exceptional productions, so I don't mind the style, just the story.
- Comic Vine
- Forums
- Gen. Discussion
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Jump to Top
Jump to Last Read
Browse Boards
- Gen. Discussion
- Bug Reporting
- Delete/Combine Pages
- Artist Show-Off
- Off-Topic
- Contests
- Battles
- Fan-Fic
- RPG
- Comic Book Preview
- API Developers
- Editing & Tools
- Podcast
- Quests
Please Log In to post.
Don't post to forums
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Moderator Hangout
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Spam Museum(Or search for a more specific forum)
(Bring back the main forum list)
Forums
Main boards
Gen. Discussion
Bug Reporting
Delete/Combine Pages
Artist Show-Off
Off-Topic
Contests
Battles
Fan-Fic
RPG
Comic Book Preview
API Developers
Editing & Tools
Podcast
Quests
Popular wiki boards
- Marvel Cinematic Universe
- X-Men
- Spider-Man
- DC Extended Universe
- Dragon Ball Universe
- Hulk
- Thor
- Batman
- Thanos
- Superman
Top posters
Kairan1979
18834 posts
RIKR2
15514 posts
the_stegman
12837 posts
waezi2
12234 posts
Guru_Crack
10239 posts
StormShadow_X
9475 posts
Ready_4_Madness
8944 posts
Battle_Forum_Junkie
8453 posts
rogueshadow
8305 posts
RustyRoy
8189 posts
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
- Advertise
- Partnerships
- API
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Ad Choice
- Help
- Careers
© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Use your keyboard!
- ESC
Log in to comment
Log in to comment