I don't know how the fight against ANH versions would go. My gut feeling is that Vader and Ben would take it. Kyle and Jaden stand a good chance against AOTC versions, but there's no way they're getting past ROTS Anakin.

Pretty much this. They take AOTC versions because Obi Wan can't handle them by himself, and Anakin is waay too cocky and arrogant to help him properly. Vader and Ben are too much for them, mostly because OP gives them composite feats, which means Vader has his comicbook/book feats from Legends which includes him beating 10 jedi masters at the same time and similar stuff.

Gotta disagree about ROTS though. I think they might actually take ROTS round too, though with high difficulty.

This is because Kyle can carry this with his scaling feats. He beat force buffed Desann, who according to Grandmaster Luke himself was CRAZY powerful and we actually see Grandmaster Luke and Desann fight briefly and Desann was WINNING THE FIGHT. Yeah. Obviously GM Luke wasn't as powerful 2 years after ROTJ as he was later on, but he should still be WAY above Anakin. Even if we lowball this feat it still proves Kyle is a superior duelist to Anakin.

Dies at 2 and 3.

ROTS versions stomp

Vader and Ben take it

only R1 is debatable

1. Team AotC gets stomped.


2. Team RotS wins.


3. Team ANH loses.

Anakin and Obi-Wan all rounds.

First round is the only one that goes for Kyle and Jaden while the second one is stomp for Anakin and Obi-Wan, while the last round is well...hard to tell.

@thoromdil: Maybe I underestimate Desann (and by consequence Jedi Knight-era Kyle Katarn). Post-ROTJ Luke's performances are perhaps the most crazily inconsistent in the Legends timeline, but I've always held the opinion that Luke could (and logically should) have been able to deal with Desann very easily, and that if he wasn't fighting in character he'd have annihilated him.